Timeline of the Fund's Work on Family Caregiving
• United Hospital Fund begins its participation in a multi-stakeholder collaborative, funded by the federal Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Initiative (PCORI), focused on assessing transitional care programs in terms of their impact on patients and family caregivers.
• Developed collaboratively by a Boston Medical Center/Boston University School of Medicine research group and staff from the United Hospital Fund, a new tool—“Understanding and Enhancing the Role of Family Caregivers in the Re-Engineered Discharge”—is added to the Project RED toolkit, a nationally used intervention that helps hospitals create safe and effective patient discharges. (June)
• Some 19 New York hospitals and 28 nursing homes begin working together to improve patient transitions (from hospital to nursing home and nursing home to emergency department) through a new quality improvement initiative—IMPACT (IMprove Processes And Care Transitions) to Reduce Readmissions Collaborative—jointly launched by United Hospital Fund and Greater New York Hospital Association. (February)
• The Fund announces an agenda of ten action steps to improve transitions in care and contribute significantly to the transformation of the nation’s health care system, as well as a culminating report about the three-year initiative Transitions in Care–Quality Improvement Collaborative.
• Carol Levine, director of the Families and Health Care Project at United Hospital Fund, presents testimony on HIPAA before the U.S. House of Representatives' Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, Committee on Energy & Commerce, explaining how misinterpretation of the HIPAA law is impeding constructive communications between health care providers and family caregivers, to the detriment of patients.
• The Fund and AARP Public Policy Institute partner to produce Home Alone: Family Caregivers Providing Complex Chronic Care, a report based on a national survey that found that 46 percent of family caregivers perform medical and nursing tasks for care recipients with multiple chronic physical and cognitive conditions.
• The Fund continues to enrich the Next Step in Care website, adding three new guides and monitoring visitor preferences to inform future improvements.
• The Fund launches a new initiative, Transitions in Care–Quality Improvement Collaborative, or TC–QuIC—involving 25 heath care providers working in teams to make safer and more effective transitions of seriously, chronically ill patients between health care settings.
• To improve the working relationship between family caregivers and health care providers, the United Hospital Fund launches the Next Step in Care website: www.nextstepincare.org.
• Terry Gross interviews Carol Levine on the NPR program “Fresh Air,” after the publication in the New York Times Magazine of Carol’s essay titled “Two Husbands.”
• The Next Step in Care Campaign is launched; materials for family caregivers and health care providers are created and tested, promotional materials are produced, a website is developed and launched, and the campaign and its goals are presented at numerous meetings and conferences.
• United Hospital Fund staff conduct plans for Next Step in Care: Family Caregivers and Health Care Professionals Working Together, the first effort in transition care to specifically involve family caregivers.
• “This Case is Closed: Family Caregivers and the Termination of Home Health Care Services for Stroke Patients,” by Carol Levine, Steven M. Albert, Alene Hokenstad, Deborah E. Halper, Andrea Y. Hart, and David A. Gould, is published in Milbank Quarterly (84(2):305-331), providing the first study of caregiver experiences of transitions from home care services; based on a research study of 99 family caregivers of stroke and brain injury patients following discharge from hospital or short-term nursing home stay, this report finds that even while home care services were in place, families provided 70 percent of the care.
• In her keynote speech at the launch of the New York City Family Caregiver Coalition, Carol Levine formally presents two documents—a policy agenda and an ethical framework—intended to guide future health reform discussions on behalf of New York State's family caregivers; project results in the State’s creation of the Family Caregiver Council in 2007.
• The United Hospital Fund and National Alliance on Caregiving release a study “Young Caregivers in the U.S.: Findings from a National Survey,” co-authored by Gail Gibson Hunt, Carol Levine, and Linda Naiditch; the study is the first survey of young caregivers aged 8 to 18 in the United States.
• A companion article, “Young Adult Caregivers: A First Look at an Unstudied Population,” by Carol Levine, et al., is published in the American Journal of Public Health; it reports survey results for caregivers aged 18 to 24.
• The United Hospital Fund hosts a conference, “Family Caregiving in a Changing World” (March).
• The book Family Caregivers on the Job: Moving Beyond ADLs and IADLs, edited by Carol Levine, is published by United Hospital Fund; its content is based on working group discussions of measures that look only at custodial care for determining what family caregivers do.
• The book The Cultures of Caregiving: Conflict and Common Ground among Families, Health Professionals, and Policy Makers, edited by Carol Levine and Thomas H. Murray, is puiblished by Johns Hopkins University Press; based on a collaborative project between the Fund and the Hastings Center, the book provides recommendations for collaboration around transitions.
• The United Hospital Fund, in collaboration with the National Alliance on Caregiving and with support from MetLife, publishes a series of brochures on hospital discharge for family caregivers and discharge planners.
• The United Hospital Fund Family Caregiver Grant Initiative, a three-year, $2 million effort to develop family caregiver support programs in seven New York City hospitals, is completed; results are published in “Making Room for Family Caregivers: Seven Innovative Hospital Programs,” by Carol Levine.
• The United Hospital Fund hosts a conference, “Building Successful Family Caregiver Programs,” which includes sessions on reaching the family caregiver audience (May 2).
• “A Survey of Family Caregivers in New York City: Findings and Implications for the Health Care System,” by Carol Levine, Alexis Kuerbis, David A. Gould, Maryam Navaie-Waliser, Penny Hollander Feldman, and Karen Donelan, is published and serves as a companion to a national survey of family caregivers conducted by the Harvard School of Public Health, Visiting Nurse Service of New York, and United Hospital Fund; it is the first survey to ask caregivers about performing medical tasks and the training received. Results from the survey are subsequently reported in "Challenged To Care: Informal Caregivers in a Changing Health System," a national survey published by Health Affairs (volume 21, number 4) in 2002.
• “The Economic Value of Informal Caregiving,” by Peter Arno, Carol Levine, and Margaret Memmott, is published in Health Affairs (18 (2): 182-88) and provides the first estimate of how much unpaid caregivers contribute to the health care system–the midrange estimate was $196 billion (reflecting 1997 data); the 2006 estimate by AARP is $358 billion.
• “The Loneliness of the Long-Term Caregiver,” by Carol Levine, is published in the New England Journal of Medicine (May 29, 340(20): 1587-90), a personal narrative about transitions and the systemic failures to address the needs of family caregivers; “The Trouble with Families: Toward an Ethics of Accommodation,” by Carol Levine and Connie Zuckerman, is published in Annals of Internal Medicine (130:148-152), providing an exploration of the tensions between health care professionals and families.
• Always On Call: When Illness Turns Families into Caregivers, edited by Carol Levine, is published by United Hospital Fund; the second edition is published by Vanderbilt University Press in 2004.
• Carol Levine is interviewed by Terry Gross on the NPR program “Fresh Air” about Always On Call.
• “Rough Crossings: Family Caregivers’ Odysseys through the Health Care System,” written by Carol Levine and published by the United Hospital Fund, is the first report to identify transitions as a critical point at which the health care system fails to include family caregivers.
• A front-page New York Times story, “Health Care Comes Home, A Special Report: Families Provide Medical Care, Tubes and All,” by Ian Fisher (June 7), features Fund work on family caregiving.
• The Fund takes the issue of family caregivers to a national level when Fund President James Tallon, Jr., calls attention to it at a “Family Reunion” hosted by Vice President Al Gore and attended by President and Mrs. Clinton on June 22.
• United Hospital Fund launches the Families and Health Care Project, the first to link the needs of family caregivers with changes in the health care system; Carol Levine joins the Fund to direct the project with the goal of building public, health care professional, and policy support for family caregivers (October).